Estate Sale vs. Auction vs. Online Selling: Which Keeps the Most Value?
Updated
When a house full of belongings has to be settled, there are four main ways to sell it: a traditional estate sale, an auction, consignment, or selling online. Each has a place. Here's how they compare on speed, effort and the value they keep, and why we combine them.
The traditional estate sale
An estate sale company prices the contents and opens the house to the public, usually over a weekend or a few days, with discounts toward the end. It's fast and empties most of a house at once.
The trade-off is reach. Every piece sells to whoever comes that weekend, at whatever they'll pay. A collector two states away who would pay far more never hears about it, and what doesn't sell is often hauled off. For a house of everyday contents on a tight deadline, that can be the right call. For a house with good furniture, art or collections, it usually leaves money on the table.
Auction
Auction houses, in person or online, are good at reaching serious buyers for particular kinds of pieces: fine furniture, art, silver, jewelry and collections. The right auction for the right piece can do very well.
But auctions are selective, results vary from sale to sale, and they aren't built for the everyday contents of a home. Sending a whole household to auction rarely makes sense.
Consignment
A consignment shop sells pieces on your behalf and keeps a share. It suits good furniture and decor that sells steadily to local shoppers. It's slower, the shop chooses what it will take, and space is limited.
Selling online
Listing pieces online puts them in front of buyers globally, regionally and through wholesale channels, not just whoever lives nearby. It's how a niche collectible finds the one person looking for it.
It also takes the most work: researching each item, photographing it, writing it up, answering questions, packing and shipping. Done piece by piece over time, it's often the approach that keeps the most value, but it isn't practical for most families to do themselves while settling an estate.
Why we combine them
As an estate sale company, we use each method where it's strongest, in this order. Family chooses keepsakes first. Then we list pieces online over time. Specialist pieces go to the dealers and auction houses who know them best. What remains can go to consignment. If a lot is still left at the end, we finish with a sale at the home, and we suggest local organizations for whatever is left after that.
We work through the contents systematically, using technology to research, list and track every piece. Given adequate time, we generally retain two to three times the value a weekend sale would. You receive an itemized record of what sold, where, for how much, and what was donated. See how our estate sales work.
Which is right for you?
If the house must be empty in two weeks and holds mostly everyday things, a traditional weekend sale may be the honest answer. If there's time, and the home holds pieces worth finding the right buyer for, a staged approach usually keeps far more. The best way to know is to have someone walk through the home with you. Before you hire anyone, read how to choose an estate sale company.
What makes The Fair Hand different
We don't compete on being the quickest or the cheapest. We compete on the quality of the work and the value it keeps for you.
Every piece researched
We work through the contents item by item, researching each piece and tracking it with technology, rather than putting a price on a whole house in a few days.
Placed where it's valued
Pieces are marketed to buyers globally, regionally and through wholesale channels, and specialist pieces go to the dealers and auction houses who know them best.
More value for the estate
Given adequate time, we generally retain two to three times the value a weekend sale would, preserving more of the estate's non-real-estate value.
A complete, honest account
You see what's in the home before anything is listed, and receive an itemized record of every sale and donation. Fees are in writing up front, with no referral fees or kickbacks.
Not sure which fits your situation?
We'll walk through the home with you and give you an honest view. The first visit is free, with no obligation.
Schedule a free consultation