The Even-Hand Rule: Settling Belongings Fairly Among Heirs
Updated
Anyone who settles an estate or looks after a trust owes the same duty to every beneficiary: to deal with them all with an even hand. Money is easy to divide fairly. A household of furniture, jewelry, paintings and keepsakes is not. Here is what the rule asks of executors and trustees, and what it should ask of anyone they hire to handle the belongings.
What the even-hand rule means
The even-hand rule, also called the duty of impartiality, is one of the oldest ideas in trust law. A trustee may not favor one beneficiary over another, or let one carry a burden the others don't share, unless the will or trust itself says otherwise. Georgia trust law asks the same of trustees, and executors settling an estate hold a similar duty to the people who inherit from it.
Even-handed does not mean identical. A will may leave a particular ring to a particular granddaughter, and that's the person's wish to honor. What the rule requires is a fair process: every beneficiary's interests weighed honestly, decisions made for good reasons, and those reasons written down. When a trustee plays favorites, courts can remove them and hold them responsible for what the estate lost.
Why belongings test it hardest
A bank account splits into equal shares in a minute. The contents of a home don't. One sibling lives nearby and is in the house every week. Another flies in for a weekend. One cared for a parent for years and feels they've earned the piano. Another remembers being promised it as a child.
Sentimental value and market value rarely line up, either. A worn kitchen table may mean more to the family than a signed painting, while the painting is worth more than everything else in the room. Without a careful process, the people who are closest, quickest or loudest end up with the most, and the family is left with hard feelings that outlast the estate.
Keeping it even: practical steps for executors
None of this is legal advice, and your estate attorney is the right person for questions about your duties. But a few habits make an even hand much easier to keep:
- Read the will or trust first. It may leave particular pieces to particular people, or say how personal belongings are to be divided.
- Make an inventory before anything leaves the house. Things that quietly go home with someone early are the most common source of family disputes.
- Get values from someone outside the family. An informed outside opinion keeps one heir from pricing what another wants.
- Choose a fair way to choose. Taking turns in an order everyone agrees to works well, as does counting chosen pieces against each person's share.
- Set disputed pieces aside. Selling or giving away something two heirs both want settles nothing and can't be undone.
- Keep one written record, and let everyone see it. What was kept, by whom, what sold and for how much, and what was donated where.
What to expect of an estate sale company
When you hire a company to sell or clear a home's contents, it acts on the estate's behalf, and its conduct reflects on you. An estate company worth trusting should be able to say plainly that it:
- Works for the estate as a whole, taking direction from the executor or trustee rather than from whichever heir calls most often.
- Explains its fees in writing before any work begins.
- Takes no hidden referral fees or kickbacks from the dealers, auction houses or shops it sends pieces to.
- Tells you about any relationship it has with a buyer, dealer or charity.
- Leaves contested pieces alone until the family or executor decides.
- Gives a complete, itemized account of what sold, for how much, and what was donated where.
- Stays in its lane, and leaves legal and tax questions to your attorney and accountant.
The standard behind our name
To deal with a fair hand is to be honest and even-handed, so this is the standard we hold ourselves to. On an estate, we take direction from the executor or trustee, not from any one heir. Our fees are explained in writing before we begin. We take no referral fees or kickbacks from the dealers, auction houses or consignment shops we work with, and if we have any relationship with a buyer, dealer or charity, we tell you.
If heirs disagree over a piece, we set it aside until the family or executor settles it. When the work is done, you receive an itemized record of what sold, for how much, and what was donated where, and it can be shared with every beneficiary so everyone sees the same numbers.
Clients may also name us as a trustee in their estate, or appoint us to the professional team that will carry out their wishes. Then the even-hand rule isn't only a good habit. It's the duty we've accepted. Read more about our approach.
Questions about fairness and estates
Does the even-hand rule mean every heir gets the same things?
No. It means every beneficiary is treated fairly under the terms of the will or trust. If the will leaves specific items to specific people, honoring that is part of being even-handed. Your estate attorney can explain what the rule requires in your situation.
Who do you take instructions from on an estate?
The executor or trustee. We're glad to hear from every member of the family, but decisions come from the person responsible for the estate.
What happens if two heirs want the same piece?
We set it aside and leave it alone until the family or the executor settles it.
Can every beneficiary see what sold and for how much?
Yes. You receive an itemized record of what sold, for how much, and what was donated where, and it can be shared with every beneficiary.
Can I name The Fair Hand in my estate plan?
Yes. Clients may name us as a trustee in their estate, or appoint us to their professional team. Your estate attorney can advise on how to set that up.
Do you give legal advice about an executor's duties?
No. We focus only on the belongings, and legal and tax questions stay with your attorney and accountant.
Settling an estate and want it handled fairly?
Our first visit is free, with no obligation of any kind.
Schedule a free consultation